In this week’s question, we’ll be dealing with a couple of issues that can arise from sources not really mentioned in this classic post.
Dear Andrew:
I recently re-entered the job market, and have been looking through postings online for a while. However, I have a few questions about some of the postings, and whether they are safe to respond to.
How important is it for the company name to be listed? And what about the organization’s website? Also, I haven’t been receiving many responses, except from organizations where my income would only be based on commissions. Should I keep looking into those?
- Diving Back In
Well, I didn’t know that we had started using pseudonyms, but other than that, I think that you have raised some valid questions. Here’s my take:
If a company can’t be bothered to put its name on its ads, that should be a red flag. Why would they be ashamed of posting that they are hiring? There’s no legal reason that they HAVE to say who they are or what they do, but considering that these posts are on public websites, they must be okay with many different people applying. If someone will not even say what their company is, that is usually a bad sign. Regardless of the copy in the post, don’t apply for it. Or if you do, don’t spend much time on your application, and definitely don’t pin your hopes on it.
As for the website, provided a name is listed, it should be easy to find. I can understand a bit of difficulty tracking down an “ACME Repairs” on Google, but a bit more info (like the city and state, or any other info in the ad that might help) can narrow down the search. And if they are not even on the front page of the search results, that’s usually a bad sign. It’s cheap to make a website, and it doesn’t take long to establish a web presence and make things look snazzy. Hell, I’ve done it for myself. Also note the quality of their website – depending on the industry that the company is in, this could also be a red flag – or a green light.
And I know that it wasn’t mentioned in the email, but if the person you’re supposed to send your application to has a generic email address on a non-corporate site (yahoo, gmail, aol, hotmail, etc), that MIGHT be a problem. It goes back to the website thing – it’s cheap and easy to have corporate emails, so what’s the problem? – although in some cases, the email might be for a specific program or position at the company (like the one I submitted a few applications to that I told you about). If you’re being asked to send your resume about an engineering job to [email protected], though, you might want to rethink it.
Finally, when it comes to commissions, it’s up to you. I’m not a fan of working for free (the company takes no risk as they don’t have to give you ANYTHING if you fail) for low reward (commission percentages are usually not that great). If you think you would excel at it and want to take the chance, go for it – but it’s an easy way for companies to make money – and for you not to.













